Expert test cases

Single · 34 · FR · I carry, my eggs · known donor only · all funded attempts used · priorities: cost, legal complexity, embryo testing (#3 = strongly preferred, not must-have)

Expected pathways (in order)

BE-PRIV-KNOWN · DK-PRIV-KNOWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Parentage (birth mother)
• 🔴 Known donor line (342-9)
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

FR public (known donor) · ES (anonymous) · GR (anonymous) · PT (unclear)

Other checks

Both pathways labelled 'Embryo testing not available here' (testing ranked #3)

Expert order (for MVP review)

data-driven

Two women · married · I carry, my eggs, donor sperm · FR + DZ · covered

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-DIUI · BE-PRIV-DIUI · ES-PRIV-DIUI

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟡 Algerian partner uses co_mother, never a father row
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

None

Other checks

Algerian partner citizenship uses the co_mother row

Expert order (for MVP review)

data-driven

Single · I carry · donor sperm (clinic/bank) · donor: Open-ID · 36 · FR · covered · no children · priorities: cost, close, fast

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-DIUI · DK-PRIV-DIUI · PT-PRIV-DIUI

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Parentage (311-25, 342-9)
• 🟢 FR citizenship (art. 18)

Near misses

ES (anonymous donors) · BE (anonymous donors – no Open-ID)

Other checks

Changing: BE anonymity 2027 · reimbursement line (68%)

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · married · I carry, partner's eggs (reciprocal IVF), donor sperm · donor: no preference · 34/37 · FR + IT · covered · priorities: fast, cost, legal (no partner question – reciprocal)

Expected pathways (in order)

DK-PRIV-ROPA · ES-PRIV-ROPA · PT-PRIV-ROPA

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟡 Parentage FR (342-10/11)
• 🟢 FR citizenship
• 🟡 IT via co-mother (non-birthing mother)

Near misses

None

Other checks

Before you start: notary before treatment

Expert order (for MVP review)

ES · BE · PT (PT and BE cost the same – a tie)

Couple · married · I carry, my eggs, partner's sperm · 41/46 · FR · covered · priorities: fast, cost, close

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-IVF-OWN · FR-PRIV-IVF-OWN · BE-PRIV-IVF-OWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Parentage (312)
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

None

Other checks

Before you start: egg collection until 43rd birthday

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Single · I carry · donor sperm + donor eggs · donor: no preference · 44 · FR · covered · priorities: fast, cost, close

Expected pathways (in order)

ES-PRIV-DEDS · GR-PRIV-DEDS · DK-PRIV-DEDS

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Parentage
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

FR public (donor-egg wait > time to 45)

Expert order (for MVP review)

ES · GR · PT (Greece ~€2,250 cheaper; Portugal far behind)

Couple · living together · I carry, my eggs, partner's sperm · 33/33 · IN (me) + FR (partner) · not yet covered → moved < 3 months, nobody works in France · priorities: cost, fast, close

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-IVF-OWN (once covered) · FR-PRIV-IVF-OWN · BE-PRIV-IVF-OWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟡 Parentage (316 recognition)
• 🟢 FR citizenship (via partner)
• 🔴 IN (no dual)

Near misses

None

Other checks

Before you start: coverage line · "only coverage missing" shown on the FR public pathway

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · PACS · I carry, my eggs, partner's sperm · 38/40 · FR · covered · one child together · all funded attempts used · priorities: cost, close, fast

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-IVF-OWN · FR-PRIV-IVF-OWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟡 Parentage (PACS → 316)
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

None

Other checks

Count starts again after a pregnancy

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · married · I carry, my eggs, donor sperm · partner: a woman · donor: no preference · 30/32 · PL + PL · covered · priorities: legal, cost, close

Expected pathways (in order)

FR-PUB-DIUI · BE-PRIV-DIUI · ES-PRIV-DIUI

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟡 Parentage FR
• 🟡 PL birth parent (PESEL/passport transcription)
• 🔴 PL co-mother
• 🟡 FR citizenship (no French parent)

Near misses

None

Other checks

Changing: EU rulings / Poland

Expert order (for MVP review)

FR · BE · DK (Spain route added 14 Oct, ~€850 cheaper than Denmark)

Couple · who would carry: someone else

Near misses

None

Other checks

Surrogacy waitlist screen (quiz stops)

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · both men · he carries, his eggs, partner's sperm · 31/34 · FR · covered · priorities: legal, close, cost

Expected pathways (in order)

BE-PRIV-IVF-OWN · DK-PRIV-IVF-OWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🔴 Parentage (not settled)
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

FR public (female civil status required)

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Single · I carry · known donor only · 39 · FR · covered · priorities: legal, close, cost

Expected pathways (in order)

BE-PRIV-KNOWN · DK-PRIV-KNOWN

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Your parentage
• 🔴 Donor's position
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

FR public (known donor) · ES, GR (anonymous) · PT (unclear)

Other checks

Home insemination mentioned only as a fact; no catalogue or identity question

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · man + woman · he carries · donor sperm · 31/33 · FR · covered · priorities: legal, close, cost

Expected pathways (in order)

BE-PRIV-DIUI · DK-PRIV-DIUI

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🔴 If he carries
• 🟡 If partner carries
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

None

Expert order (for MVP review)

same

Couple · married · I carry, my eggs, partner's sperm · 40/42 · FR · covered · priorities: embryo testing (#1), fast, cost

Expected pathways (in order)

CZ-PRIV-IVF-PGT · ES-PRIV-IVF-PGT · BE-PRIV-IVF-PGT

Legal check (expected ratings)

• 🟢 Parentage (312)
• 🟢 FR citizenship

Near misses

GR (embryo testing unclear)

Expert order (for MVP review)

ES · CZ · BE (Czech Republic ~€3,500 cheaper)